I rather like the idea of vNPCs loyal to the crown attacking the person exiled and leaving them unconscious with a notification sent to the Reeves on their channel much in the same way committed crimes do. That, or, how about this - When the Exiled person or persons is inside the city or near the pa...

To be fair - Only three players actually commented on that thread, so one can't really say the thoughts of those three players reflect most of the game populace. However, I see merit to removing it with the Tenebrae, but I also think the Tenebrae should not be able to support or subvert anyone in re...

You can't really compare priests to doctors. You need to instead compare them to RL Catholic Priests if you're really going to make a correlation here. In such cases, it actually is something that can break the oath of the confessional if a Priest went to the police about a murder, etc, and while mo...

But it doesn't help when order leadership tend to have differing interpretations. So let's say you are a priest during one GI, and they held a certain interpretation, however in comes the next GI who interprets it differently. Creates a bit of a problem. I'm not sure that's different than any chang...

> No good Davite admits to being a mage and then doesn't turn themselves in to the Inquisition. Well, that kind of sentence is an inquisitorial interpretation of the lore. There are other valid interpretations: - though the mage is a good davite, and knows not being pyred will make him become a dem...

As a counterpoint to confession, and I may be wrong, so staff might need to give some clarification here: Confession isn't just about getting a punishment. It's about going to a priest for guidance. If a person goes and confesses to being a mage, in the essence of the privacy of the confessional, I ...

I'm finding myself disagreeing that the Order doesn't feel dangerous or powerful. They regularly burn people, arrest them for heresy, and threaten to put them to Review. I know when I was playing the head of the Reeves I had to seriously consider what I could or couldn't do in regards to them when d...

I don't really see a need to allow the Knights into Southside. The Knights have historically joined in on the Reeves with a number of incidents to assist them and vice-versa. I can see the Brotherhood keeping the idea that the Knights are dangerous based on previous examples in Southside as well sim...

The problem with critical OOC discussion with others is whether or not the player is constantly doing it to everyone around them about that person. There's a point where it crosses the line of telling someone your opinion and actively painting that person into a corner of being a social pariah. You ...

That said - I don't really think punishing a player for something posted in a medium not under the control of TI is feasible. It would reflect poorly on the game and we can't really be sure who exactly it might be unless they outright admitted to it. Bad reviews do happen. My biggest concern is when...